Dieter

Law firm websites: a privacy check

We opened 961 websites of law firms and tax advisers three times each. Two out of three pass something on to third-party servers before the first click, just as many as in the other sectors of our study. Behind this, however, are two very different results: tax advisers do better than any other of the 15 sectors, while law firms rank in the lower midfield.

Sebastian SchenkLegally reviewed by Franziska Breidenbach
Last reviewed: Thursday, 29 October 2026
Law firm websites: a privacy check

Table of contents

  1. In brief
  2. Data and methodology
  3. Two professions, two results
  4. Why this carries more weight for law and tax firms
  5. Law firms: Google, analytics and the missing privacy policy
  6. Tax advisers: the cleanest sector in the study, with one peculiarity
  7. What firms can change themselves
  8. Checking your firm’s website with Dieter
  9. Conclusion

In brief

  • Two out of three law and tax firm websites (67.3%) contact third-party servers before visitors can click anything. In the other 13 sectors of our sample, the figure is 67.8%. The confidentiality that lawyers and tax advisers stand for does not automatically carry over to their websites.
  • Tax advisers are the cleanest sector in the study: tax adviser websites score an average of 57.5 out of 100 points, more than any other of the 15 sectors. We found an advertising or analytics tool running before consent on only 4.8%, and a privacy policy was missing on just one of 147 websites.
  • Law firms come 10th out of 15: on 8.8% of their websites no privacy policy can be found, and on 12.8% of the websites of sole practitioners. Only architecture has a higher share. Google Analytics loads on 9.0% of law firm websites before any decision has been made.
  • “Reject” rarely works: on 81.3% of law firm websites with third-party services, the number of third-party servers contacted does not fall after a click on “Reject”. Among sole practitioners, the figure is 85.2%.
  • Much of it is easy to fix: the most common causes are Google Fonts, Google Maps and the reCAPTCHA spam protection. If all firms simply left out what can be avoided without losing any function, the share of completely quiet websites would rise from 32.7% to 48.3%.

Data and methodology

This article is a spin-off of our “Before you click: Data Protection Report 2026”. For the report, we automatically visited 10,389 German websites from 15 sectors, each in three separate sessions with a real browser: once without any click, once after “Accept all” and once after “Reject”. The data was collected from 25 June to 9 August 2026. We recorded the third-party servers contacted, the cookies set, the security settings and whether a privacy policy can be found.

For this analysis, we singled out the websites of law firms and tax advisers and compared them with the remaining 9,423 websites from 13 sectors (basis: 10,384 unique websites; five had been recorded twice in the report):

GroupWebsitesof which sole practitioners
Law firms814439
Tax advisers14741
Law and tax firms total961480

Four points for context. First, we measure what a website does technically; we do not establish legal violations. Whether a particular contact is permitted depends on the individual case. Second, at 147 websites, the group of tax advisers is considerably smaller than that of law firms. Their gaps to the other sectors are large and all point in the same direction; individual figures should nevertheless be read as a trend. We do not analyse the 41 sole practitioners among tax advisers separately. Third, the sample is stratified by sector and not representative of the German web as a whole; this makes comparisons between sectors robust. A firm counts as a sole practitioner if, according to its legal form and register entries, it is run as a sole proprietorship. Fourth, we do not name any firms, only the recipients of the data, that is, the companies to which something flows. The assignment of recipients to purposes follows the methodology of the main report. “Reject ineffective” means: after a click on “Reject”, the website contacts no fewer third-party servers than after “Accept”; this includes websites that offer no option to reject at all. All figures may be used under the CC BY 4.0 licence with attribution. The analysis for medical practices, psychotherapy practices and pharmacies can be found in our article Medical practice websites: a data protection check.

Two professions, two results

On average, law and tax firm websites look like all the others. Separate the two professions, however, and eight of the other 13 sectors lie between them.

MetricLaw firmsTax advisersOther sectors
Third-party servers before the first click68.8%59.2%67.8%
“Reject” ineffective (websites with third-party services)81.3%72.8%75.8%
Advertising or analytics tool before consent16.1%4.8%15.0%
Contact with Google before the first click41.4%25.2%36.9%
Contact with a US provider before the first click52.0%38.1%47.7%
No privacy policy found8.8%0.7%5.5%
Security settings missing (worst grade)68.1%67.3%64.5%
All five checks passed5.7%10.2%8.4%
Average score (0 to 100)47.557.550.1

Tax advisers top the report’s ranking. Their websites achieve the highest scores, load advertising and analytics before consent least often and almost always have a privacy policy. 10.2% pass all five checks; only public sector websites do so more often. Law firms come 10th out of 15 by score. Before the click, they contact Google and US providers more often than average, and on the privacy policy they come second to last.

The measurement data do not tell us why. Both professions are subject to a comparable duty of confidentiality. But the data show where the difference arises: with Google services, with advertising and analytics tools and with the privacy policy.

Why this carries more weight for law and tax firms

Anyone who visits the website of a law or tax firm is often looking for help in a situation nobody else is supposed to notice: a dismissal, a separation, a criminal investigation, a tax back payment. Every connection to a third-party server transmits the IP address of the visitor and usually also which website the request comes from. Analytics tools also transmit which subpage was visited, for example the one on criminal defence.

The same rules apply to the page visit as to any website. Loading third-party content requires a legal basis under the GDPR. Anyone who stores or reads information on visitors’ devices needs their consent, unless this is strictly necessary to provide a service explicitly requested (§ 25 of the German Telecommunications Digital Services Data Protection Act, TDDDG). For analytics tools, this exception is narrow: according to the guidance of the German Data Protection Conference (DSK), even simply measuring visitor numbers is “not per se” part of the basic service, and the cost-effectiveness of advertisements “as a rule only serves the primary interests of the website operator”. The Regional Court of Munich I (LG München I) awarded a website visitor €100 in damages because a website loaded Google Fonts from Google’s servers without asking (judgment of 20 January 2022, 3 O 17493/20). And the German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has ruled that even the loss of control over one’s own data can constitute compensable damage (judgment of 18 November 2024, VI ZR 10/24).

For law and tax firms, professional law comes on top. At the latest when someone describes their matter via the contact form, the firm learns something in the exercise of its profession. This is what the duty of confidentiality refers to: for lawyers in § 43a(2) of the Federal Lawyers’ Act (BRAO), for tax advisers in § 57(1) of the Tax Advisers Act (StBerG). If the firm uses service providers who can see such enquiries, for example the host or a form or appointment booking service, it may only give them access to the extent necessary for the service. It must select them carefully and conclude a contract with them in text form that binds them to confidentiality (§ 43e BRAO, for tax advisers § 62a StBerG). This comes in addition to the data processing agreement under the GDPR. The same rules apply to AI tools; what to bear in mind there is explained by our sister project Klaus in the article AI in law firms.

Law firms: Google, analytics and the missing privacy policy

Google services are the most common cause. 41.4% of law firm websites contact Google before the first click, more than in the other sectors (36.9%). Usually it is fonts, embedded maps or the reCAPTCHA spam protection: these three load on 37.0% of law firm websites before the click, compared with 31.4% in the other sectors. All three can be served from your own server or loaded only on click without the website losing anything.

Advertising and analytics before consent: as often as elsewhere, but more often with Google Analytics. On 16.1% of law firm websites, an advertising or analytics tool runs before anyone could consent. That is close to the average of the other sectors (15.0%). What stands out is who is behind it:

  • Google: on 14.6% of law firm websites, an analytics or advertising service from Google loads before the click, most frequently Google Tag Manager (11.2%), Google Analytics (9.0%, other sectors 6.8%) and addresses from Google’s advertising network (5.9%).
  • Cookies before the decision: on 8.0% of law firm websites, Google Analytics sets its “_ga” cookie before visitors can consent or refuse at all. In the other sectors, the figure is 6.0%; among tax advisers, it is a single website.
  • Meta: on 3.2% of law firm websites, a Meta service, such as the Facebook pixel, reports in before the click.

Anyone who wants to know what their website achieves needs either consent that is obtained before loading or a method that works without third-party servers and without cookies.

One in twelve law firm websites without a privacy policy. On 72 of 814 law firm websites (8.8%), no privacy policy can be found. Among sole practitioners, the figure is 12.8%, roughly one in eight websites; 56 of the 72 websites belong to sole practitioners. Of the 15 sectors in the study, only architecture has a higher share (11.5%); among tax advisers, it is 0.7%. On top of that, 49 of the 72 websites without a privacy policy still contact third-party servers before the click. Anyone who wants to read up there on where their data goes will find no answer. The GDPR requires that visitors learn, at the time of collection, who is responsible, for what purposes and on what legal basis data is processed and to whom it goes (Art. 13 GDPR), and in an “easily accessible form” (Art. 12(1) GDPR).

“Reject” almost never works for sole practitioners. On 81.3% of law firm websites with third-party services, clicking “Reject” does not change the number of third-party servers contacted. Among sole practitioners, the figure is 85.2%, among small firms 76.4% and among medium-sized firms 77.6%. Often there is simply no option to reject, or the services load regardless of what anyone clicks.

Not a platform problem, but default settings. Unlike medical practices with their appointment booking portals or pharmacies with their sector-specific platforms, sector-specific services hardly play a role for law firms: rating widgets load on 2.6% of websites before the click, lawyer directories and other content services on 2.1%. The data outflow arises in the website’s own setup. 56.9% of law firm websites run on WordPress; of these, 48.2% contact Google before the click. On 82.3% of them, the server’s basic security settings are missing. However, this is not a law firm problem: across all sectors, they are missing on 82.8% of WordPress websites.

Tax advisers: the cleanest sector in the study, with one peculiarity

Tax advisers lead on almost every metric. 40.8% of their websites are completely quiet before the click, compared with 32.2% in the other sectors. We found advertising and analytics tools running before consent on 7 of 147 websites (4.8%), less often than in any other sector. And only a single website had no privacy policy that could be found. Google is also involved less often: 25.2% of tax adviser websites contact Google before the click, compared with 41.4% of law firm websites.

One peculiarity of the sector is embedded sector-specific content. On 10 of 147 tax adviser websites (6.8%), content from the servers of a large sector service provider for tax firms loads as soon as the page is opened, on 9 of them via its website service. According to the provider, firms use it to obtain news feeds, client information and videos, which they embed in their website using an integration code. That is convenient for the firm, and the provider is based in Germany. Nevertheless, visitors’ data flows to a third party before they have decided anything. Whether cookies are set and what data the provider receives cannot be seen from the outside. It is worth asking the provider or the agency, naming the service in the privacy policy and checking whether the content can be loaded only on click.

A second peculiarity is website builders. 19.0% of tax adviser websites contact the infrastructure of a website builder before the click, compared with 14.3% in the other sectors, most frequently the builders of large German hosting providers (8.8%) and of a large international website builder provider (5.4%). These connections are part of the product; the firm can hardly switch them off without changing provider.

So even the best sector is not perfect. Six out of ten tax adviser websites contact third-party servers before the click, “Reject” does not work on 72.8% of the websites with third-party services, and the security settings are missing on 67.3%. But the lead shows that the website of a law or tax firm can be considerably more restrained without much effort.

What firms can change themselves

Because the cause is usually a default setting, the solution is usually a setting. The steps are sorted by impact:

  1. 1Serve fonts from your own server, load maps and reCAPTCHA only on click. This step alone makes an additional 10.3% of all law and tax firm websites completely quiet, and as many as 11.1% of law firm websites. Everything remains usable for visitors; the map and spam protection only appear after a click. Switching over the fonts usually takes half a day.
  2. 2Start analytics and advertising only after consent. In the tag manager, you can set analytics and advertising tags to load only after consent has been given. Then check whether the “_ga” cookie is still set on the first visit. If you only want to know how many people visit the website, a simple count on your own server is often enough; the German Data Protection Conference expressly mentions log files without personal data for this purpose.
  3. 3Make the privacy policy reachable from every page. A link in the footer of every page is enough. The policy must cover every service the website embeds, from the map service and the host to embedded sector content.
  4. 4Test the reject button. Open the website in a private browser window, click “Reject”, open the “Network” tab in the developer tools and see which third-party addresses still show up. Takes five minutes.
  5. 5Check the contact form and service providers. Find out who can technically read the enquiries from the form: the host, a form, appointment or chat service. With these service providers, you usually need a data processing agreement and a confidentiality undertaking in text form. Widgets, videos and sector content are best loaded only on click.
  6. 6Set the server’s security settings. Four to five lines in the server configuration; they are missing on 68.0% of law and tax firm websites.

Added up: if every firm simply left out what can be avoided without losing any function, 48.3% of law and tax firm websites would be completely quiet before the click instead of 32.7% today. What then remains are things with a genuine purpose, such as analytics tools, website builders and sector content. Each of them needs its own legal basis, and analytics and advertising usually need consent. Where consent is required, the “no” must also get through technically. When you need a banner at all is explained in our guide Cookie banner: when is it required?. What else you can check on your website yourself is shown in our website self-check with twelve checkpoints.

Checking your firm’s website with Dieter

You can run the same three-state test that we used to collect the data for this study on your own website: the website scanner in the GDPR check-up is free, requires no sign-up and shows you in under a minute which recipients your website contacts before the click, after “Accept” and after “Reject”, which cookies are set and whether the security settings are right. The report is written so that you can read it without prior knowledge or pass it straight on to your agency.

Whatever remains on the website after that must be included in the privacy policy. Dieter’s privacy policy generator detects embedded services automatically via a website scan, has over 1,000 services integrated and, when embedded via API, stays up to date automatically when something changes. How a complete privacy policy is structured is explained in the guide How to create a privacy policy, and what belongs in a contract with service providers in the article Data processing agreement (DPA).

Conclusion

Law and tax firm websites pass something on before the first click just as often as the websites of the other sectors in our study. Behind the average are two very different professions. Tax advisers show that restraint is possible: little advertising, almost always a privacy policy, the highest score of all sectors. At law firms, Google services load more often before the first click, Google Analytics included, and sole practitioners in particular often lack a privacy policy. The good thing about it: most causes are default settings that can be changed in a few hours. For professions whose most important promise is confidentiality, this effort is particularly worthwhile.

Author

Sebastian Schenk

Co-Founder & CEO

Lawyer and data protection officer. Drives product vision at simply Legal and ensures Dieter is sound legally and in practice.

Sources and further reading

Frequently asked questions

Does a law firm website need a cookie banner?

Only if it uses services or cookies that are not strictly necessary for the website, such as analytics tools, embedded maps or videos without a click-to-load solution. If nothing loads from third-party servers before a decision is made and the website accesses the device only to the extent technically necessary, no consent banner is needed. You still need the privacy policy.

Does a small firm’s website also need a privacy policy?

Yes. Practically every website processes visitors’ data; even the server usually logs the IP address when the page is opened. Under Art. 13 GDPR, you must therefore provide information on who is responsible, for what purposes and on what basis data is processed and to whom it goes. The information must be easily accessible, ideally via a link on every page. If you use a template from the time before the TDDDG, you should compare it with the services your website actually embeds today.

May I use Google Analytics on my firm’s website?

As a rule, only with prior consent. Google Analytics sets cookies and transmits data to Google; that is not strictly necessary to provide the website (§ 25 TDDDG). The order matters: first consent, then loading. If you only want to count visits, you can often do so with an evaluation on your own server, without third-party services and without cookies.

Does the duty of confidentiality already apply to enquiries via the contact form?

The duty of confidentiality covers everything that becomes known in the exercise of the profession (§ 43a(2) BRAO, § 57(1) StBerG). If someone describes their matter in the form, there is much to suggest that this is included. If service providers such as the host or the form service can read the enquiries, you need a confidentiality undertaking in text form with them in addition to the data processing agreement (§ 43e BRAO, § 62a StBerG).

Does my firm need a data protection officer?

It is mandatory if, as a rule, at least 20 people are permanently engaged in the automated processing of personal data (§ 38 of the German Federal Data Protection Act, BDSG) or if the requirements of Art. 37 GDPR are met. According to Recital 91, the client data of an individual lawyer is not to be considered large-scale. The repeal of the 20-person rule has been announced but not adopted (as of October 2026); more on this in the article DPO requirement: will the 20-person rule be scrapped?.

How do I check my firm’s website myself?

The quickest way is Dieter’s free GDPR check-up, which runs the same scan as this study. Without a tool, you can use your browser: open the page in a private window, launch the developer tools and check in the “Network” tab which third-party addresses appear before any click and after “Reject”. Also check whether the privacy policy is linked from every page.

This article reflects the position at the date of publication. We update our content when the law changes.

Related articles

Dieter helps you avoid fines

Ready to go

Dieter takes care of your data protection.

Get started without a demo call and set up your data protection in a few steps.

Get started